Bluray Electra Glide in Blue (Camera Obscura) Booklet
Easy Riders, Raging Cops
Electra Glide in Blue in the Context of New Hollywood Cinema
By Marcus Stiglegger
Note: This text contains spoilers and should only be read after enjoying the film.
A dramaturgically flawed first feature
that unwinds a story without inner tension.
Questionable its advocacy of crackdowns
to shut down crime.
Encyclopedia of International Film
1.
At the heart of North American cinema is the Western – the ‘American cinema par excellence’ not just since André Bazin’s formulation. The Western was born in the frontier myth, the idea of a latent frontier between civilization and wilderness that must always be readjusted. The Westerner is the man of the frontier and works to expand that frontier – first westward, then southward. But even as space was declared the last frontier, it became clear that the borders within the country were always closing. today we speak of an Inner Frontier, the internal borders that divide the country and its people, from which springs racism, conflicts between urban and rural, between modernity and tradition. With the divisive presidency of Donald Trump, this Inner Frontier has been publicly re-discussed – specifically in terms of a ‘white and Christian supremacy’ that confronts African American and indigenous interest groups, among others. What seemed established for over 150 years is proving to be fragile and questionable. Today, the U.S. is a deeply divided country, with the deep rifts of religion, skin color, and wealth running through it. The Western initially affirmed these conflicts in terms of white supremacy (classic phase of the 1930s to 1940s), until John Ford demonstrated latent racism in the 1950s with a film like The Searchers (1956), based on the genre-defining superstar John Wayne, of all people.
With the beginning of the 1960s, the Western had finally become a myth and the classic Hollywood of the studio era said goodbye. American cinema did not achieve a renaissance until the late 1960s: Films like The Graduate (1967), Bonnie & Clyde (1967) or Easy Rider (1969) also appealed to a young audience and showed an awareness of the country’s inner conflicts. The road movie – a later heir to the Western – became the preferred genre, because it clearly showed that search for oneself that the U.S. had always been on, especially when one was not in the East Coast metropolises. Restlessness and aimlessness characterized a new generation that was no longer willing to accept the values of their parents (and grandparents). New frontiers were explored, the “wild young men,” as the posters to Easy Rider put it, consumed drugs, sought ‘free love’ and allied themselves with society’s marginalized outsiders. The indigenous population became the real Americans and a fashionable as well as ideological figure of identification. The late Western around 1970 discovered in the ‘Indians’ a metaphor for another America, beyond predation and racism. And so the generation of hippies around 1970 only intensified the generational conflict.
While the young guns of New Hollywood showed solidarity with the outsiders (Hal Ashby, Martin Scorsese, Mike Nichols, Robert Altman), old sceptics stepped up to the plate and manifested a new genre that they placed alongside the road movie: the police film. This is not to say that there hadn’t been police films in Hollywood before (in the film noir era, for instance) – but films like Dirty Harry (1971) and French Connection (1971) were a purposeful response to the libertinage of the hippies and acid people. Against sex, drugs and beat music, the authoritarian cop now stepped in as a regulator, keeping order like the sheriff once did in frontier-land. Richard Slotkin calls this a “Regeneration Through Violence,” the idea that targeted counter-violence could ultimately bring social peace – the “good man with a gun,” as invoked by the NRA gun lobby. But even in these films there are fractures and ambivalences. It is not only within the diegesis, the cinematically staged world, that the transgressions of the police officers are discussed; the films themselves sometimes appeared to liberal critics as ‘fascist’ (as the famous critic Pauline Kael repeatedly pointed out). From today’s perspective, the films of Don Siegel and William Friedkin reflect above all the inner discord, the generational conflict of those years that shaped the USA. The era of New Hollywood is almost idealized today for this ambivalence. But even in this environment of ambivalence, there are works that still raise questions and provoke today. One such film is the cop/road movie Electra Glide in Blue / Harley Davidson 344 (1973) by James William Guerico, which was sometimes defamed as conservative propaganda when it was released (including in the Encyclopedia of International Film cited above).
2.
It begins with puzzling moments. The film works with questions and refuses to give clear answers. This has been mercilessly reproached by liberal critics. Electra Glide in Blue takes the side of an underprivileged person: The motorcycle cop John Wintergreen (in the German version he is called Winterberg) is not only of conspicuously small stature, he also strives professionally for higher goals. He wants to become a detective, because at first he is left only with the fetishized black leather uniform. Guerico introduces us to the details of this uniform in stylized freeze frames during the opening credits: the heavy duty belt with braided pattern, the high, shiny stock boots, the holster and the shimmering leather jacket. When Wintergreen finally marches out of the precinct garage into the sunlight in full gear to triumphant orchestral sounds, memories of Kenneth Anger’s homoerotic underground etude Scorpio Rising (1964) inevitably arise.
Wintergreen patrols the deserted highways of Arizona with his partner Zipper. When he is informed by his informant Crazy Willie about a suicide by shotgun, Wintergreen believes that this case is actually a homicide, since the victim shot himself in the chest instead of the head. Investigating detective Harve Poole agrees with him that it could be a homicide after a .22 slug was found among the buckshot in the man’s chest during the autopsy. Also, a large sum of money appears to be missing. Wintergreen gets his wish, but his joy is short-lived: he begins to identify increasingly with the hippies, who are being bullied by the other officers – including Detective Poole. When Poole discovers that Wintergreen has been sleeping with his girlfriend Jolene, he arranges for Wintergreen to be reassigned to street duty. The film’s idiosyncratic dramaturgy dictates that Wintergreen not only solve the murder, but also uncover what appears to be a related theft. But this solving will leave Wintergreen lonely.
Conrad C. Hall, the film’s cinematographer congenially captures this growing isolation of the ambitious ‘little man’. When we leave him in the middle of the highway at the end, the camera keeps backing up, following the dead straight highway until we are barely physically aware of the protagonist. The iconic Western landscape in the background becomes more and more dominant, the land engulfs the individual – the human hardly has a chance in this monumental space. Gradually, the colors escape and the image finally transforms into the John Ford country of the classic Western, or rather its melancholic echo. Electra Glide in Blue is a pessimistic film about the truth of North America after the era of the Western. The boundaries between lawmen and criminals become more and more blurred; whoever appears to be a victim can become a perpetrator at any time. Yet the real enemy always lurks within the system itself.
3.
That the later cult film Electra Glide in Blue exists at all can be considered a minor miracle. The directorial debutant James William Guercio once accepted the fee of one dollar in order to have the budget available for Conrad Hall as cinematographer. However, it soon became apparent that Guercio and Hall disagreed on the final style of the film. Guerico was aiming for the big western, while Hall was planning a darker film noir. A compromise was reached in which Guercio could shoot the exterior scenes in a manner reminiscent of John Ford’s great western classics, while Hall lit all the interior scenes of the film as he saw fit. The film was not supported by the Arizona Highway Patrol, so much of the film was shot without a permit in Monument Valley and Fountain Hills, Arizona.
Conrad Hall’s lavish cinematography accentuates the film’s subtext, placing it somewhere between Western nostalgia, countercultural road movie, and critical police film. Hall’s style still makes the film seem monumental today, exaggerating its rather incidental crime story into the mythic. The utopian ‘Regeneration Through Violence’ is doomed to failure here in the face of a ‘Circle of Violence’. Of course, the film is never affirmative towards the violent cops, but depicts the whole society ambivalently. The firearm – the carefully guarded relic of the frontier era – becomes the lowest common denominator. The film begins and ends with the shotgun, which Hall’s images visually link to other swansongs to the ‘American Dream’: In Cold Blood (1967) by Richard Brooks (also cast with Robert Blake), Cool Hand Luke (1967) by Stuart Rosenberg, and Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid (1969) by Sydney Pollack.
The real enigma and phenomenon, however, is James William Guercio, a firmly established music producer, musician and songwriter by 1973. He was known at the time for his work producing Chicago’s early albums, as well as the early recordings of The Buckinghams and Blood, Sweat & Tears. In the mid-1970s, Guercio managed The Beach Boys and was a member of their backing band. Members of the band Chicago appear in supporting roles in the film, including Peter Cetera, Terry Kath, Lee Loughnane and Walter Parazaider, as well as Hawk Wolinski from the Guercio-produced band Madura. Chicago members also collaborated on the soundtrack produced by the director. The soundtrack album at the time included a four-page fold-out poster of Robert Blake standing next to his motorcycle on a cliff overlooking Monument Valley. This triumphant image may be prototypical of a film that deals aggressively with the American mythos. Guerico only worked in the film industry as a producer and director for a short time. In 1981, he produced another Robert Blake film, Second-Hand Hearts.
4.
Also a film history myth is the lead actor Robert Blake, now known to many as the white-painted ‘Mystery Man’ from David Lynch’s Lost Highway (1996). Blake, however, made his Classical Hollywood debut as a child actor in the 1939 film Bridal Suite, and went on to star in over 40 episodes as a regular member of the Little Rascals in their less successful late period at Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer. From 1942, he went by the name Bobby Blake and starred alongside Stan Laurel and Oliver Hardy, among others. In the 1950s and 1960s, the adult Blake continued his acting career, mainly in television appearances, but without achieving greater fame. Blake achieved his breakthrough only in 1967 with the portrayal of Perry Smith in the film In Cold Blood, which, based on Truman Capote’s novel of the same name, reported on a true murder case for which Smith was sentenced to death by hanging. If Smith was already half-blood, Blake was cast directly as a Native being pursued by a sheriff in Tell Them Willie Boy is Here / Bloody Trail (1969) by Abraham Polonsky. His starring role in Electra Glide in Blue earned him a Golden Globe Award nomination in 1974, and somehow his preceding roles played into the ambiguity of John Wintergreen’s character: his strikingly short stature, his dark taint, his black streaks, the lurking reticence of the downtrodden…. He also played a detective in the title role in the television series Baretta between 1975 and 1976, for which he won the Emmy Award in 1975 and the Golden Globe Award in 1976.
Although he never became a well-known Hollywood star after that, Blake managed to hold his own as a character actor until the 1990s. In 2001, Blake was accused of shooting his wife Bonnie Lee Blakley out of jealousy. He was incriminated by two stuntmen who claimed that he had tried to persuade them to commit a contract killing. Due to implausible testimony and a lack of evidence, Blake was eventually acquitted in 2005.
5.
In retrospect, Electra Glide in Blue appears to be an unjustly often forgotten classic of New Hollywood, the era in which the American film industry reinvented and reformed itself. Like the best films of the time, the film deals with the myth of Hollywood cinema as well as with the roots and problems of North American society. Its constellation of characters and its visual design reflect in an iconically condensed way the inner division of a country that was (and is) neither at peace with its own history nor with its countercultural phenomenon. At the heart of the USA, then, also lies the endless spiral of violence, only temporarily delayed by the often longed-for “good man with a gun”. John Wintergreen is disillusioned by the corruption of the system and in the end crosses the ‘Inner Frontier’ between ‘Culture’ and ‘Counterculture’, between cops and hippies. But his gesture of reconciliation is not understood and ends in a death that could hardly be more tragic and typical on an American highway. Shot out of a misunderstanding, left behind as a shattered relic on the highway that runs straight into mythical country. The ‘Old West’ died at the latest with Peckinpah’s The Wild Bunch (1969) – and the U.S. present is frozen in the consciousness of this death….
The Author:
Marcus Stiglegger, professor of films studies in Muenster and Ludwigsburg, is one of the most active film experts in the German-speaking world. He has published over 40 books, produced bonus material for over 200 films, and composes music with his band Vortex. In 2019, he co-founded the podcast Projektionen – Kinogespräche with Sebastian Seidler.